Skip to content
Fire on the Lake Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Pickup
  • Order Delivery
  • Gift Cards
  • Gallery

Menu

Download PDF Menu

SMALL PLATES

Mozzarella Garlic Bread
Rustic Ciabatta. Roasted Garlic. House Shredded Mozzarella. Arugula. Flaky Salt. $15

Seasonal Charcuterie Plate
Prosciutto. Soppressata. Fresh Mozzarella. Seasonal Accompaniments. Brick Oven Crackers. $23

Cauliflower “Wings”
Oven Roasted Cauliflower clusters.
Bang Bang Sauce -or- FOL Medium Buffalo. $14

Oven Baked Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi Pasta, Cheese Blend, Topped with an aged Manchego-White Cheddar bubbly crust.
Choice of Sauce: Garlic Pecorino Cream -or- White Garlic Truffle Sauce. $15

INSALATE

Caprese
Mixed Greens. Fresh Mozzarella. Cherry Tomatoes. Orange Balsamic Reduction. Fresh Basil. Sea Salt. Cracked Pepper. $15

Antipasto
Mixed Greens. Olives. Soppressata. Mortadella. Fresh Mozzarella. Cherry Tomatoes. Artichoke Hearts. Shaved Parmesan. House Oil. $18

Caesar
Chopped Romaine. White Anchovies. Sea Salt. Parmesan Crisps. House-Made Dressing. $16

Add chicken cutlet to your salad $5

BRICK OVEN PANUOZZI

Choice of chips: Regular, Sour Cream & Onion, Jalapeño

Conesus
Mortadella. Salami. Prosciutto. Spinach. Stracciatella Cheese. Roasted Red Peppers. Red Onion. Sicilian Aioli. $18

Hemlock
Artichoke Hearts. Mushrooms. Basil. Cherry Tomatoes. Garlic Pecorino Cream. Red Onion. $17

Otisco
Chicken Cutlet. Fresh Mozzarella. Arugula. Hot Honey. Cherry Tomatoes. Truffle Garlic Cream. $18

Canadice
Speck Ham. Red Onion. Branco Aioli. Arugula. Stracciatella Cheese. $18

PIZZAS

Canandaigua
Basil. Stracciatella Cheese. Red Sauce. EVOO. Cherry Tomatoes. Roasted Garlic. Flaky Salt. $17

Honeoye
Artichoke Hearts. White Garlic Truffle Sauce. Roasted Red Peppers. Spinach. Mushrooms. House Shredded Mozzarella. $18

Seneca
Calabrian Salami. Calabrian Peppers. Red Sauce. House Shredded Mozzarella. Hot Honey. Rosemary. $18

Owasco
Vodka Sauce. Speck Ham. House Shredded Mozzarella. Roasted Garlic. $17

Skaneateles
Red Sauce. House Shredded Mozzarella. Fennel Sausage. Basil. Red Onion. Fresh Ground Parmesan. $17

Cayuga
Garlic Pecorino Cream. Thin Sliced Russet Potatoes. Caramelized Onion. Fresh Shaved Parmesan. Prosciutto. House Shredded Mozzarella. Basil. $18

Keuka
Pistachios. Stracciatella Cream. Calabrian Chili. Mortadella. Basil. Lemon Zest. Rosemary. $18

Any pizza can be made with a gluten-friendly cauliflower crust. Additional charge of $4

DESSERT

Brick Oven Baked S’mores
Graham Crackers. Marshmallows. Hershey’s Chocolate. Caramel. Whipped Cream. Cherry. $12

Fire on the Lake Logo

Fire on the Lake

Order Pickup

Gift Cards

Hours

Wednesdays - Sundays 1:00pm-9:00pm


Contact

58 Lakeshore Drive
Canandaigua, NY 14424

(585) 412-6116

InstagramFacebook


© 2025 Fire on the Lake All Rights Reserved | Crafted by Green Phoenix Creative