Skip to content
Fire on the Lake Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Pickup
  • Order Delivery
  • Gift Cards
  • Gallery

Menu

Download PDF Menu

SMALL PLATES

Mozzarella Garlic Bread
Rustic Ciabatta. Roasted Garlic. House Shredded Mozzarella. Arugula. Flaky Salt. $15

Seasonal Charcuterie Plate
Prosciutto. Soppressata. Fresh Mozzarella. Seasonal Accompaniments. Brick Oven Crackers. $23

Cauliflower “Wings”
Oven Roasted Cauliflower clusters.
Bang Bang Sauce -or- FOL Medium Buffalo. $14

Oven Baked Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi Pasta, Cheese Blend, Topped with an aged Manchego-White Cheddar bubbly crust.
Choice of Sauce: Garlic Pecorino Cream -or- White Garlic Truffle Sauce. $15

INSALATE

Caprese
Mixed Greens. Fresh Mozzarella. Cherry Tomatoes. Orange Balsamic Reduction. Fresh Basil. Sea Salt. Cracked Pepper. $15

Antipasto
Mixed Greens. Olives. Soppressata. Mortadella. Fresh Mozzarella. Cherry Tomatoes. Artichoke Hearts. Shaved Parmesan. House Oil. $18

Caesar
Chopped Romaine. White Anchovies. Sea Salt. Parmesan Crisps. House-Made Dressing. $16

Add chicken cutlet to your salad $5

BRICK OVEN PANUOZZI

A brick oven sandwich originating in Gragnano, Campania, Italy . It consists of ingredients sandwiched together between two layers of dough.

Choice of chips: Sea Salt, All Mixed Up, Sweet Maui Onion

Conesus
Mortadella. Salami. Prosciutto. Spinach. Stracciatella Cheese. Roasted Red Peppers. Red Onion. Sicilian Aioli. $20

Hemlock
Artichoke Hearts. Mushrooms. Basil. Cherry Tomatoes. Garlic Pecorino Cream. Red Onion. $18

Otisco
Chicken Cutlet. Fresh Mozzarella. Arugula. Hot Honey. Cherry Tomatoes. Truffle Garlic Cream. $19

Canadice
Speck Ham. Red Onion. Branco Aioli. Arugula. Stracciatella Cheese. $19

PIZZAS

Canandaigua
Basil. Stracciatella Cheese. Red Sauce. EVOO. Cherry Tomatoes. Roasted Garlic. Flaky Salt. $17

Honeoye
Artichoke Hearts. White Garlic Truffle Sauce. Roasted Red Peppers. Spinach. Mushrooms. House Shredded Mozzarella. $18

Seneca
Calabrian Salami. Calabrian Peppers. Red Sauce. House Shredded Mozzarella. Hot Honey. Rosemary. $18

Owasco
Vodka Sauce. Speck Ham. House Shredded Mozzarella. Roasted Garlic. $17

Skaneateles
Red Sauce. House Shredded Mozzarella. Fennel Sausage. Basil. Red Onion. Fresh Ground Parmesan. $17

Cayuga
Garlic Pecorino Cream. Thin Sliced Russet Potatoes. Caramelized Onion. Fresh Shaved Parmesan. Prosciutto. House Shredded Mozzarella. Basil. $18

Keuka
Pistachios. Stracciatella Cream. Calabrian Chili. Mortadella. Basil. Lemon Zest. Rosemary. $18

Any pizza can be made with a gluten-friendly cauliflower crust. Additional charge of $4

DESSERT

Brick Oven Baked S’mores
Graham Crackers. Marshmallows. Hershey’s Chocolate. Caramel. Whipped Cream. Cherry. $12

Fire on the Lake Logo

Fire on the Lake

Order Pickup

Gift Cards

Hours

Closed for Winter. We'll see you in Spring!


Contact

58 Lakeshore Drive
Canandaigua, NY 14424

(585) 412-6116

InstagramFacebook


© 2026 Fire on the Lake All Rights Reserved | Crafted by Green Phoenix Creative